top of page
Search

Two Months, One Cookie, and Zero Success

courtneypoguephoto
24 hours ago
4 min read

I pulled another tray of Fluffernutter cookies out of the oven and knew before they even cooled that I'd failed again. The marshmallows had scorched into little black puddles, the edges were hard as rocks, and the middles were somehow chewy in all the wrong ways. When I tried to lift one off the pan, it fell apart in my hand. I was well into my second month of trying.


The short version: AI tools can produce content in seconds, but they can't test, taste, or judge whether something actually works. AI is best used as one tool inside a larger system that still includes your email platform, your strategy, and a human who checks the quality and adds real experience.

Two months of tiny tweaks


I worked on that Fluffernutter cookie for over two months. Every week I'd make one small tweak to the recipe, bake another batch, take notes, and try again. Week after week, they came out hard, overly chewy, burnt, or crumbling apart, and sometimes all four at once.


I never did get that recipe to work. And I'll be honest, that still bugs me a little. But it also taught me something I think about constantly now. A recipe isn't real until it's been tested, tasted, and proven in an actual kitchen. Anyone can write a list of ingredients and steps. Making it work is the hard part.


Ask an AI tool for a Fluffernutter cookie recipe and it will hand you one in about two seconds. It will look perfect. It will sound confident. And it will never have been baked by anyone, because AI has never burned a marshmallow, never watched a cookie spread into one giant sheet, and never stood in a kitchen at the end of a long week wondering what went wrong this time.


AI isn't your system


That's where a lot of businesses are right now. There's nothing wrong with being efficient, and saving time and money is smart. AI is a great tool for it, and I use it all the time, including to get my first thoughts down for posts like this one. But I'm still doing the work. I double-check it, add my own thinking, and make sure it sounds like me, because speed is only a win if the quality is still there.


AI is an information in, information out system. It's very good at taking what you give it and returning something that sounds right, but it isn't making sales for you, your automations don't live inside it, and it doesn't know which of your clients just had a hard month or which offer you're quietly retiring. It can be part of your systems. It can't be your system. You still need your email platform, your workflows, your strategy, and a person who understands how all of it fits together and can tell when something's off.


Everything it gives back also depends on what goes in. If the information you feed it is thin or wrong, what comes out will be thin or wrong too, just written more confidently. That's a big reason so much content online has started to sound the same. Nobody tested it. Nobody tasted it.


Being findable is the other half


There's another side to information in, information out. More and more people find answers by asking their phone or an AI tool, and those tools can only pull from content they can find. I realized that a lot of my own best content, the solid, helpful stuff full of real experience, wasn't being found. My website was in good shape and my social content was strong, but it was all competing for the same space, and my email newsletter, as good as it was, didn't show up in search at all.


Your experience works the same way. The stories from your client calls, the lessons from your trainings, and the things you've learned over years in your field are exactly what search tools are looking for. But if they only ever live in an inbox or a private program, nobody outside your list will ever find them. That's a big part of why I started writing here. Publishing somewhere searchable means real experience can be found by the people looking for it, whether they're using Google or asking an AI.


So use the tools and let them save you time. Then do what they can't, which is to test it, taste it, and put yourself into it. People trust us because we've done the work, burnt marshmallows and all, not because we have a bot that's good at sounding like us.


Frequently asked questions


Can AI replace a human content writer?

AI can speed up drafting, but it can't test ideas, understand your clients, or judge whether content fits your strategy. The best results come from using AI as a tool while a person handles the thinking, voice, and quality control.


How do I make my content show up in AI search results?

Publish your expertise somewhere searchable, like a blog or Substack, and use the words your audience actually searches for. AI tools can only reference content they can find.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Courtney's Content Services

  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook

©2025 by Courtney Fetty.

bottom of page